Home

Things to Do

Places to Eat

Places to Stay

Events

5 Must try pizza places in St. Augustine

St. Augustine, with its cobblestone streets and historic charm, is not only a haven for history buffs but also a paradise for pizza lovers. From traditional Italian flavors to unique twists on classic pies, the Ancient City offers a diverse array of pizza joints that will satisfy any craving. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, here are the five best places to get pizza in St. Augustine:

1. Pizza Time: Tucked away on St. George Street, Pizza Time is a cozy spot known for its New York-style slices. With a casual atmosphere and friendly service, this family-owned pizzeria serves up generously sized pies loaded with fresh toppings. Whether you opt for a classic cheese slice or a specialty pie like the “Meat Lover’s,” you’re guaranteed a delicious experience at Pizza Time.

2. Pizzalley’s Chianti Room: Situated in the heart of the historic district, Pizzalley’s Chianti Room is a beloved local favorite. This Italian eatery offers a diverse menu featuring gourmet pizzas crafted with high-quality ingredients. From the savory “Margherita” to the indulgent “Four Cheese Pesto,” each pie is expertly prepared and bursting with flavor. Pair your pizza with a glass of wine from their extensive selection for the perfect dining experience.

3. Mellow Mushroom: Known for its funky atmosphere and creative pizzas, Mellow Mushroom is a popular chain restaurant located on Anastasia Boulevard. Step inside and you’ll be greeted by psychedelic decor and a laid-back vibe. Their menu boasts an eclectic range of specialty pies, from the “Holy Shiitake Pie” topped with mushrooms, caramelized onions, and garlic aioli to the “Kosmic Karma” featuring red sauce, feta, mozzarella, spinach, and sun-dried tomatoes. With its diverse options and relaxed ambiance, Mellow Mushroom is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts.

4. Carmelo’s Marketplace: For a taste of authentic Italian cuisine, look no further than Carmelo’s Marketplace. This charming deli and market, located on San Marco Avenue, offers a mouthwatering selection of pizzas made with traditional recipes and imported ingredients. Whether you opt for the classic “Margherita” or the indulgent “Prosciutto e Rucola,” each pizza is crafted with care and attention to detail. Pair your meal with a freshly baked cannoli for the ultimate culinary experience.

5. St. Augie’s Pizza: A local institution, St. Augie’s Pizza has been serving up mouthwatering pies to the St. Augustine community for years. Located in a quaint corner of the city, this family-owned pizzeria offers a cozy atmosphere and a menu packed with flavor. Their pizzas feature a perfect balance of crispy crust, tangy sauce, and melty cheese, making each bite a delight. Whether you’re a fan of the classic “Cheese” or the adventurous “BBQ Chicken,” St. Augie’s has something for everyone. Don’t forget to pair your pizza with one of their tasty appetizers or salads for a truly satisfying meal experience.

¬†Whether you’re craving a classic slice or a gourmet masterpiece, St. Augustine has no shortage of fantastic pizza options to satisfy your appetite. From quaint family-owned pizzerias to trendy eateries, each establishment offers a unique culinary experience that celebrates the art of pizza-making. So the next time you find yourself in the Ancient City, be sure to indulge in a slice of heaven at one of these top pizza spots.